The literary New York bar that has not been Disneyfied.
The White Horse Tavern has stood at the corner of Hudson and West 11th Street since 1880. Originally a longshoreman's bar serving the Hudson piers, it was the second-oldest pub in Manhattan when the docks closed in the 1960s. The conversion to literary bar happened slowly through the 1950s, when Norman Mailer, Jack Kerouac, James Baldwin, and Anaïs Nin began to drink here in shifts. The room and the tile floor have not been changed in any way the regulars would notice.
Two interconnected rooms. A small front bar where the longshoremen drank. A larger back room with the famous corner table where Dylan Thomas held court for his last week of life. The table is still in its corner, with a small framed photograph of Thomas above it. The bar leases the building from a 1965 family agreement that holds the rent below market.
Why this matters. The White Horse is the rare West Village bar that has resisted both gentrification and theming. The owners have refused to lean into the Dylan Thomas legend. There is no exhibit. There is no Dylan Thomas cocktail. The corner table is just a table you can sit at, with a photograph above it that the regulars treat as wallpaper.
Dylan Thomas's corner table.
The corner table is in the back room, against the south wall, with a view of Hudson Street through the window to your left. Dylan Thomas sat there nightly in November 1953 during his fourth American reading tour. On the night of November 4th, 1953, he drank what he claimed was eighteen straight whiskies, walked the four blocks to the Chelsea Hotel, collapsed on the floor of his room, and died five days later at St Vincent's Hospital. The eighteen whiskies story has been disputed by his biographers but the table is real and the photograph above it is real.
You can sit there. The table is first come, first served. The bar does not reserve it for VIPs and does not limit how long you sit. Most regulars sit there at some point during a long evening. Order a Tullamore Dew. Look at the photograph. Look at Hudson Street. Read.
Tullamore Dew, Guinness, hamburger.
- Tullamore Dew: nine dollars neat. The Dylan Thomas drink. Order it neat in a small rocks glass.
- Guinness: ten dollars a pint. The longshoreman tradition. Pours slow, settles in two stages, comes with a clean head.
- The hamburger: sixteen dollars. Often called the best dive bar burger in Manhattan. Half pound, American cheese, served on a soft potato roll with crinkle-cut fries.
- The wine list: short and unsurprising. The house red is fine. Most regulars skip it.
- The thing nobody knows: the bar pours a small Powers Irish whiskey at seven dollars, off menu. Ask for the "house Irish." The bartenders will know what you mean.
Sunday at 1pm. The literary lunch.
The White Horse opens at 11am every day and closes at 2am. The 11am to 1pm window is the slowest of the week. Sunday at 1pm is the literary lunch hour. The bar is half full, the burger is at its best, the corner table is open, the regulars are reading the Sunday Times Book Review.
The peak is Friday and Saturday between 8pm and midnight, when the bar is three deep and the back room is loud. The literary tourists arrive between 7pm and 8pm and stay an hour. After 11pm the bar reverts to a local crowd. The honest evening hour is Tuesday or Wednesday at 9pm: the back room is half full, the bartenders pour slowly, the corner table is yours within fifteen minutes.
The outdoor seating in summer is on the corner of Hudson and 11th, twelve sidewalk tables. Useful for a 6pm pre-dinner pint. Not useful for the Dylan Thomas experience, which requires the back room.
What is on the wall, and what was almost not.
The framed photograph of Dylan Thomas above the corner table was donated by a regular in 1979. It is a press photograph from his 1952 reading tour, taken on a sidewalk somewhere in Greenwich Village. The frame is original from 1979. The glass has been cleaned twice.
In 2015 a representative of the Dylan Thomas Centre in Swansea offered to replace the frame and the photograph with an archival quality reproduction donated by the estate. The bar refused. The owner said the frame was the bar's, and the photograph was the bar's, and the Welsh government could keep their offer. The original is still up. The dust on the frame is documented in three different food columns.
Sixty dollars per person, with the burger.
Plan for fifty to seventy dollars per person for a three-hour visit including the burger. Two whiskies at nine, two pints at ten, sixteen for the burger, twenty percent tip. A pair: a hundred and twenty dollars. A four-top sharing two burgers: a hundred and eighty.
The bar accepts cards. Tipping is twenty percent on the bill. Bartender tips on cash drinks are pooled with the back-room servers. Three dollars per drink in cash on the bar is the local norm.
The West Village holdouts and the literary tourists.
The White Horse draws three populations. The first is a small group of long-tenure West Village residents, mostly in their sixties and seventies, who have drunk here since the 1980s. The second is the New School and NYU graduate student crowd, who use the back room as an after-class workshop space. The third is the literary tourist contingent, often graduate students from European universities, sometimes whole reading groups on a New York pilgrimage.
The bar is the rare Manhattan room where the literary tourist is not an intrusion. The bar's identity is partly a literary site, and the regulars accept the visitors as part of the deal. Strike up a conversation about Dylan Thomas with the regular two stools down. They will know the dates. They may know more about the dates than you do.
How not to be the worst person at the White Horse.
- Do not order eighteen whiskies as a joke. The bar will not serve them and the staff will not laugh.
- Do not photograph the corner table while someone is sitting at it. Wait until the table is empty, then take one photograph, then put the phone away.
- Do not request the corner table by phone. The bar does not reserve it. First come, first served.
- Do not bring a stag party. The bar will not refuse service but the back room will resent your group.
- Do not order a Long Island Iced Tea. The bartenders will pour it but the regulars will note you.
- Do not tap on the photograph above the corner table. The frame is original from 1979.
- Do not, under any circumstances, recite Dylan Thomas at the table. The regulars have heard "do not go gentle" enough times. Keep it to yourself.
Burger at White Horse, walk to Stonewall, end at Marie's Crisis.
The classic West Village evening: arrive at the White Horse at 6pm for a burger and a Tullamore Dew, sit in the back room for two hours. Walk to the Stonewall Inn on Christopher Street at 9pm for a beer and the working clientele of New York's most important LGBTQ landmark. End at Marie's Crisis on Grove Street at 11pm for the show-tunes piano bar that has run continuously since 1929.
For more bars in the area, see our New York city guide, the West Village cocktail bars, and the hidden gems list.
Yes. The most preserved literary bar in Manhattan.
The corner table is exactly what you want it to be.
White Horse Tavern is the bar that proves a New York literary site can survive being a literary site. The owners have refused to theme. The corner table is a corner table. The photograph is the original 1979 frame. Dylan Thomas's eighteen whiskies are not commemorated with a cocktail. Order a Tullamore Dew, sit in the back room, eat the burger, look at Hudson Street through the window. The bar will reward you with the room as it actually was, not the room as a museum imagines it should be.
Rating: Number eleven on our 50 best dive bars list. Best literary dive bar in New York.