Devil's Advocate occupies a converted Victorian pump house at the bottom of Advocate Close in the Old Town. The space is dramatic, exposed stone walls, vaulted ceilings, and a long industrial bar. The whisky list runs to over 200 Scotches with a focus on independent bottlers and rare casks.
The cocktails are well built and use Scotch heavily. The Penicillin is a benchmark. The whisky tasting flights are thoughtfully constructed, three drams of related styles for around £30, and the bartenders are knowledgeable.
The crowd is mid-thirties Edinburgh locals, whisky enthusiasts, and travellers seeking atmosphere. Pair with The Bow Bar for a complete Old Town whisky evening.