Address
9 Advocate Close, Old Town, EH1 1ND
Old Town, Edinburgh
Old Town, Edinburgh
Best For
Whisky tasting, cocktails, atmospheric setting
Opening Hours
Daily17:00–01:00
Reservations
Recommended
Dress Code
Smart casual
Price Range
$$ · Drams from £8
Our Take
Whisky in a Victorian Pump House
Devil's Advocate occupies a converted Victorian pump house at the bottom of Advocate Close in the Old Town. The space is dramatic — exposed stone walls, vaulted ceilings, and a long industrial bar. The whisky list runs to over 200 Scotches with a focus on independent bottlers and rare casks.
The cocktails are well built and use Scotch heavily. The Penicillin is a benchmark. The whisky tasting flights are thoughtfully constructed — three drams of related styles for around £30 — and the bartenders are knowledgeable.
The crowd is mid-thirties Edinburgh locals, whisky enthusiasts, and travellers seeking atmosphere. Pair with The Bow Bar for a complete Old Town whisky evening.
What to Order
Whisky Tasting Flight
Three related drams. Bartender curates by region or style. Around £30.
Penicillin
Blended Scotch, lemon, ginger honey, smoky Islay float. Benchmark version using Scottish whiskies.
Old Fashioned
Built with Scotch from the back bar. Demerara, Angostura, citrus oil.
Single Malt by the Glass
Around 200 options. Bartender will recommend. Range of prices and ages.
