Editorial
Two cities. Two completely different philosophies on what a bar should be. London perfects the craft cocktail. Berlin tears up the rulebook. Walk into a cocktail bar in Soho and you'll find bartenders in custom suits pouring two-decade-old spirits into glasses that cost more than dinner. Walk into a bar under the S-Bahn in Berlin and you'll find someone who thinks menus are oppressive and that a proper cocktail is whatever you can throw together with what's available. Both approaches are compelling. Both have devoted followings. And neither city is willing to concede defeat. So which city actually wins? That depends entirely on what you want from a night out.
London's cocktail scene has become the gold standard of European bar culture. It's technical, ambitious, and obsessed with the details that most drinkers will never notice but that somehow make everything taste better. The best bars in London operate like laboratories where bartenders are simultaneously artists, chemists, and philosophers.
Start with Nightjar in Shoreditch—a speakeasy hidden behind a vintage shop front that could double as a curiosity cabinet. The bar program is as much about theater as it is about liquid. Every drink tells a story, every ingredient is sourced with precision. Order the house special and you're not just getting a cocktail; you're getting the result of weeks of testing and refinement. The bar staff know more about spirits provenance than most sommeliers know about wine. The Beaufort Bar at the Savoy offers the opposite end of the spectrum: classic elegance, white glove service, and cocktails that taste like they've been perfected over decades—because many of them have.
Then there's Callooh Callay in Soho, where the bartenders seem to have memorized every cocktail ever written and can execute them all at the highest level. And Candelaria—no, wait, that's our next city. But you understand the point. London has cocktail bars that operate at a level of precision and craft that elevates the category. The culture is one of professionalism, quality, and an almost British obsession with doing things properly. Reservations are expected. Dress codes exist for a reason. The bartender will correct you gently if you're holding your glass wrong. And somehow, despite all of this formality, the best London bars manage to be welcoming and genuinely fun.
For those seeking the very best examples of the craft, London also offers numerous hidden gem bars tucked throughout the city, from mews houses in Mayfair to underground cocktail dens in the East End. The entire city has become a template for craft cocktail bars worldwide.
Berlin's bar scene exists in almost total opposition to London's. Where London says "reservation," Berlin says "show up whenever." Where London says "dress code," Berlin says "wear whatever." Where London says "bartender knows best," Berlin says "you know what you like, make it yourself if you want." This isn't a lack of craft in Berlin—it's a different philosophy entirely. The craft is still there. It's just hiding under layers of anti-pretension.
Buck and Breck on Rosenthaler Platz is the exception that proves the rule. It's one of the world's top-ranked bars, it takes reservations (unusual for Berlin), and it has a tasting menu format that rivals any fine dining restaurant. The bartenders have studied their craft obsessively. But even here, the vibe is loose. The bartender will chat with you about where the ingredients came from, but not in a way that feels like a lecture. And once you leave Buck and Breck, Berlin's philosophy reasserts itself.
The Tausend bar, hidden under the S-Bahn tracks, represents the true Berlin spirit: you descend into a basement, the space is moody and slightly dodgy, and the bartenders are experimenting with ingredients and techniques that haven't been codified into any rulebook. Monkey Bar at the 25hours Hotel is slightly more refined, but still maintains that sense that the rules are guidelines, not requirements. In Berlin, the drinking culture is one of experimentation, freedom, and a healthy skepticism toward anything that smells like marketing. You want a cocktail? Fine. But it's going to be made on the bartender's terms, with whatever spirits they think are interesting right now.
Check out Berlin's cocktail bars and hidden gems and you'll find that many of them operate without websites, without Instagram, and sometimes without even signage. The bar discovers you; you don't discover the bar. This approach has created a scene that's simultaneously more exclusive and more democratic—exclusive because you have to know where to go, democratic because once you're there, nobody cares who you are or what you're wearing.
London's pub culture has been revolutionized in the last decade. The craft beer movement arrived and transformed what was once a fairly uniform landscape of mild ales and lagers into something far more interesting. Breweries like Kernel, Pressure Drop, and Beavertown have made London one of Europe's finest beer cities. You can find incredible IPAs, experimental sours, and wild fermentations in pubs throughout the city. The culture around beer has become sophisticated and knowledgeable without losing its essential pub-ness.
Berlin, however, has been brewing beer for 800 years. This is the home of Pilsner. Berliner Weisse is a Berlin invention. When Berliners talk about beer culture, they're not discovering something new—they're maintaining a tradition that predates modern nationalism. The German approach to beer is one of consistency and respect for style. You know exactly what you're getting when you order a Pilsner in Berlin because the beer is made to exacting standards that have been refined over centuries. For sheer consistency and depth of tradition, Berlin wins. For innovation and experimentation, London is catching up fast.
This is where the cities diverge most dramatically. In London's top cocktail bars, expect to pay £14-18 per cocktail. A night out with drinks at Nightjar or the Beaufort Bar will cost you more than a nice dinner in most cities. Premium spirits, custom ice, garnishes flown in from who knows where—it adds up. In Berlin, the best cocktails cost EUR 9-13. You might pay less. Some bars operate on a sliding scale or a donation basis. The economics of the scene are fundamentally different.
Berlin wins decisively on value. A night out in Berlin costs half what it would in London, and the drinks are often just as good. The trade-off is that Berlin's bars often feel more chaotic, less polished. London is paying for the experience and the setting. Berlin is giving you the cocktail and letting you figure out the rest.
There is no clear winner because the question itself assumes both cities are trying to do the same thing. They're not. London has built the world's most impressive cocktail infrastructure. The bars are beautiful, the staff is knowledgeable, the drinks are consistently excellent. But you're paying for all of that, and you're operating within a certain set of expectations and codes. Berlin has rejected most of those codes entirely. The drinks are just as good, often cheaper, and the experience is looser, more experimental, and more genuinely unpredictable. Choose London if you want the definitive cocktail experience, perfect service, and don't mind dressing up. Choose Berlin if you want freedom, surprise, and the feeling that anything could happen tonight.
In the end, the best answer is to spend time in both cities. Let London show you what precision and craft can achieve. Let Berlin show you what happens when you strip away all the rules and start from scratch. The cocktail world is richer for having both approaches.
Sofia Reeves, Senior Editor. Sofia has covered the European bar scene for 11 years, from London's cocktail parlours to Berlin's underground clubs. She writes for barsforkings from her base in London.
Our latest picks for the cocktail bars, hidden gems, and neighbourhood spots worth visiting in London this season.
Berlin's underground bar scene continues to evolve. Here are the spots our editors are drinking at this month.
How does London's cocktail precision compare to Amsterdam's canal-side charm? We find out.
One email, every Friday. Our editors’ top bar picks across 60+ cities — places worth the detour.