Indianapolis
Indianapolis's best-kept bars are the ones locals don't broadcast. These ten are worth finding. A working editorial ranking, refreshed every quarter.
Fountain Square · $$$
Indy's most awarded cocktail bar.
Mass Ave · $$$
Cocktail bar inside the Alexander Hotel.
Fletcher Place · $$
Distillery tasting room with a serious cocktail bar attached.
Mass Ave · $$
Cafe-bar-pastry hybrid.
Fletcher Place · $$$
Restaurant-bar with one of Indianapolis's tightest natural-wine lists and a craft-cocktail menu.
Downtown · $
Heritage blues bar from 1850.
Indianapolis rewards drinkers who scout neighbourhoods, and the spread below reflects that. You'll find spots in Mass Ave, Fountain Square, Broad Ripple, and beyond — each picked for what it does best, not how loud its marketing is. We focus on small rooms, low signage, locals-only feel, no tourist crowds; we ignore venues that prioritise volume over craft. The order is a working ranking, not a leaderboard — number one isn't always your number one. Read the notes and pick the room that fits the night you're planning.
Best for: quiet nights, off-the-tourist-track drinking, locals-only feel. Most rooms here run from late afternoon until 1 or 2am; the busier ones lift their door policy on weekends and we've flagged those where it matters. Save the page, send it to whoever you're meeting, and let the rest of Indianapolis take care of itself.
A working editorial ranking. Numbers are guidance, not gospel. Pick the room that fits your night.
Looking beyond Indianapolis? See our guide to the best hidden gem bars worldwide, or compare hidden gem bars city by city.