Conversation-friendly. Easy to leave. Drinks under kr20. Ten bars our editors keep recommending when readers ask where to take a first date.
First dates are the highest-stakes hospitality test in the city. The room has to be quiet enough to hear each other but full enough that a long silence does not feel cavernous. The drink list has to give a reader who does not drink a graceful out. The exit has to be easy. Our editors have spent the past year vetting Reykjavik's cocktail rooms specifically for this question — where do you take someone you might not see again, but might see for the next twenty years?
Where the editors take a first date in Reykjavik
The first six picks below are the editors' default — the rooms we send a friend to first when they ask. Each is followed by a recommendation we have ordered ourselves at least three times. Click any bar name to read the full review, signature drink notes, neighbourhood guide and how to book.
At Pikko's in City Centre, the pikko mojito arrives in a coupe and the bar staff move at the right pace. Easy to leave gracefully if it is not working. Easy to extend if it is. The exit has a quiet street, not a queue. Editors' rating in our database: 4.5 of 5.
Slippbarinn, in City Centre, the door is unmarked enough to feel discovered and known enough to be reliable. Conversation here travels well. The acoustics are tuned for two people leaning in, not eight people leaning out, which is exactly what a first date needs. Editors' rating in our database: 4.7 of 5.
At Apotek Restaurant Bar in City Centre, the room is what it should be — quiet without being precious, busy without being a queue. Conversation here travels well. The acoustics are tuned for two people leaning in, not eight people leaning out, which is exactly what a first date needs. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
In City Centre, Flora the flora botanical is on the menu year-round for a reason and the bartenders pour with intent. Conversation here travels well. The acoustics are tuned for two people leaning in, not eight people leaning out, which is exactly what a first date needs. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
At Dillon Whiskey Bar in City Centre, the door is unmarked enough to feel discovered and known enough to be reliable. Pick a corner two-top and order across the menu — the staff are unfussed, the room is dim enough that you can read each other but bright enough that you can read the menu. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
Orson Cocktail Bar, in City Centre, the room is what it should be — quiet without being precious, busy without being a queue. Pick a corner two-top and order across the menu — the staff are unfussed, the room is dim enough that you can read each other but bright enough that you can read the menu. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
Order: Orson Highball
The full Reykjavik guideEvery bar category, every neighbourhood. Our complete Reykjavik guide covers cocktail bars, rooftops, hidden gems and more across the city.
These last four are the editors' deeper-cut picks. Smaller rooms, more specific energy. If the first six feel obvious to you — meaning you have already been — start here.
Veltusund Cocktail Bar, in City Centre, the veltusund sour is on the menu year-round for a reason and the bartenders pour with intent. Pick a corner two-top and order across the menu — the staff are unfussed, the room is dim enough that you can read each other but bright enough that you can read the menu. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
Sumac Grill Bar, in City Centre, the sumac highball is on the menu year-round for a reason and the bartenders pour with intent. Conversation here travels well. The acoustics are tuned for two people leaning in, not eight people leaning out, which is exactly what a first date needs. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
Rok Bar sits in City Centre and the door is unmarked enough to feel discovered and known enough to be reliable. Pick a corner two-top and order across the menu — the staff are unfussed, the room is dim enough that you can read each other but bright enough that you can read the menu. Editors' rating in our database: 4.6 of 5.
At Geiri Smart Bar at Canopy in City Centre, the room is what it should be — quiet without being precious, busy without being a queue. Pick a corner two-top and order across the menu — the staff are unfussed, the room is dim enough that you can read each other but bright enough that you can read the menu. Editors' rating in our database: 4.5 of 5.
Order: Geiri Smart Manhattan
Weekly editorial
The bars worth going to, weekly.
One email per week. The bars our editors are recommending right now, across 72 cities worldwide.
Free. Unsubscribe anytime.
More Cocktail Bars in ReykjavikThe full editor-curated list of Cocktail Bars in Reykjavik, with neighbourhood notes and signature-drink picks.
If you are reading this article, you are probably between the booking confirmation and the actual date. Three rules. Book the table — walking in with a reservation says you put thought in. Pick the bar nearest to public transport, not the one with the best view. And keep dinner reservations elsewhere; if the conversation works, you are going to want a second venue.
If you are between stages: our companion Reykjavik guidesFrom first-date picks to anniversary rooms - every occasion in Reykjavik our editors cover, cross-linked.
Sponsored placements on this article, on the Reykjavik city guide, and across the barsforKings network. Contact us to put your bar in front of the right audience.
